Best Fleet Management Metrics For Better Output

Around 79% of US fleets had reported rising operational costs mainly due to inflation. Guess the factors that topped the list? It was fuel (31%), vehicle breakdowns (14%), and maintenance (13%). Yet I have seen many fleet managers who are still relying on spreadsheets or outdated methods to track KPIs. 

‍

If you are not tracking your fleet's important metrics, then you are flying blind and losing money with every mile. In modern fleet management, decisions should be made on data as it can cut fuel costs, prevent breakdowns, and ensure timely deliveries. However, it is important to keep in mind that not all fleet management metrics are capable of serving the purpose. 

‍

So, I have compiled for you the 18 essential fleet management metrics that smart operators watch and how you can use them for efficiency, safety, and profitability. Whether you manage five vehicles or fifty, these KPIs will alert you to troubles before they grow too big and find savings that lie hidden in your operation.

‍

So, let's get started and make every mile worth it.

What are fleet management metrics?

Fleet-management metrics are numbers or data points used to analyze how well the vehicles and drivers are performing.  For example, these metrics are like a fitness tracker for your fleet; just as a smartwatch tracks your step count, heart rate, and sleep to keep you healthy, metrics keep track of fuel consumption, vehicle downtime, driver safety, and delivery schedules to ensure smooth business operations.  These metrics provide you with the answers to questions like: 

• Are we spending too much on fuel?

• Which vehicle should go in for maintenance?

• Are drivers actually following the rules of safety?

• Have deliveries been able to make it on time to the customers?

Without knowing these metrics, you are going to be just guessing, and that is a risky business when you manage so many moving parts.

‍

Who uses fleet management metrics, and why do they matter?

{{demo_tms="/styles/components"}}

‍

Fleet management metrics are used by different stakeholders. Let’s check out who uses these metrics and for what purpose.  

• Fleet Managers: These metrics reveal a lot of information about fuel consumption, maintenance programs, and vehicle downtime.

• Dispatchers & Operations Leads: For operation leaders or dispatchers, metrics like route efficiencies, delay times, and delivery times are critical. They help assign jobs, avert delays, and optimize fleet movement.

• C-Suite Executives: The top-level leaders use metrics like the total cost of ownership or cost per mile to make strategic decisions affecting short-term profit margins, customer satisfaction, and long-term growth.

Therefore, once everyone goes by the same metrics, they look toward the same goals—be it cost-cutting or improving on-time delivery.

Common mistakes when tracking fleet metrics

It's easy to assume that gathering more data always leads to better decisions, but this isn't always the case. Many teams fall into time-draining traps that create confusion or are optimized down the wrong path. Here is what you should be careful about:

‍

1. Chasing vanity metrics

Some of the metrics, such as "number of trips completed," look neat on paper but do not necessarily show real-time performance or profitability. A high number of trips would mean nothing if over half of them were underutilized or late.

‍

2. Measure everything but do nothing

Trying to collect dozens of metrics without planning puts pressure on your team. Concentrate on KPIs relevant to your centre of business activities. For instance, you can reduce downtime or cut fuel costs rather than just tracking everything you can.

‍

3. Ignoring the context

Low utilization rate may not mean anything negative. For instance, some vehicles are needed only for seasonal use. If you don’t know why a particular number may be high or low means you may end up solving a problem that does not exist or, worse off, ignoring the ones that truly exist. 

‍

4. Depending on dashboards alone

Dashboards are good, but I bet they cannot replace healthy discussions. If your drivers and operational teams don't understand the numbers or see how the data relates to their day-to-day working styles, no good changes will ever come out of it.

The 18 most important fleet management metrics to track

There are plenty of fleet management metrics to track and each one of them has their significance. Let’s explore them. 

‍

1. Fuel & sustainability metrics

If you're serious about operational savings and ESG goals, this is where you start. Tracking these metrics shows how efficiently your vehicle consumes fuel. This means it also gives you an idea of the kind of environmental footprint you’re leaving behind. 

‍

A. Fuel consumption

It’s the amount of fuel that a fleet uses for the distance covered or for a period. It is measured in liters or gallons per 100 kilometers or per mile.

‍

Why it's important:

Fuel is one of the biggest items on a fleet's operating costs ledger. So, if you do not keep track of this, you are losing money. I've witnessed fuel costs drop by 10 to 15 per cent simply by identifying fuel-guzzling vehicles and choosing smarter routes. Less fuel means fewer emissions; that's a win for your wallet and sustainability goals.

‍

How to calculate it: 

Fuel consumption is simply the total amount of fuel used divided by the total distance travelled. A vehicle that uses 600 liters of fuel to cover 6,000 km has a fuel consumption of 0.1 liters per kilometer. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

Light-duty vehicles should aim for 8 to 12 liters per 100 kilometres, whereas the heavier trucks, such as fully-loaded long-distance tractors, often use 35- 60L/KM. The real target is to reduce these numbers year after year. Hence, if you are not improving at least 5 to 10% per year, something really is wrong.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Begin with route planning to optimize shorter and smarter routes 

• Keep tires inflated properly

• Train the drivers on eco-driving measures

‍

B. Idle time percentage 

This fleet management metric shows the time while engines in a vehicle are running, but the vehicle is not moving. The vehicle stands in an idle position. For example, the vehicle could be waiting in a traffic jam or at a loading dock, or just with the AC running.

‍

Why it matters:

Idle time produces fuel consumption without any acceptable output. It also produces emissions and engine wear and tear. The U.S. Department of Energy says that trucks during idling consume nearly 0.8 gallons of fuel per hour. Multiplying that for a couple of hours in a week, and there can be like a dozen vehicles, and the cost piles up really fast.

‍

How to calculate it:

Idle time is divided by the total on-time of the engine, multiplied by 100. Thus, if your truck idled for 2 hours out of 10 hours of engine time, your idle percentage would be 20%.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

I’d say keep the percentage below 10. Last mile delivery or logistics with trained drivers wants to keep it below 5%. However, anything below 10 works fine. 

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Use telematics to watch idling in real time. 

• Set up alerts when it crosses a threshold. Some fleets even automate engine shutdown after a defined idle time. 

• Make sure you train your drivers. Raising awareness about fuel wasted in idling can create some change. 

‍

C. Carbon emissions per vehicle

This one measures how much carbon is emitted by a vehicle in operation. It just shows the real emission footprint of your fleet from an environmental perspective. So, you can get away with all the guesswork. 

‍

Why it matters: 

Let's be very clear: these days, the sustainability of your operations is in the limelight so much that everybody wants to know about this. This is the kind of metric they will be interested in if you are going after enterprise contracts or with partners who care about ESG. It also helps you decide whether you want to shift to EVs or just fine-tune your routes. 

‍

How to calculate it: 

Take the value of the total fuel used, multiplied by the fuel’s emission factor. For example, diesel will emit 2.68 kg of CO₂ per liter. So, a truck emitting 1,000 liters would be equivalent to emissions of roughly 2,680 kg. Divide that by the distance covered, and you'll have emissions per kilometer: a useful benchmark to go by. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets: 

There is no universal target, but most fleets look at 20-30 percent emissions reduction in the next couple of years. Some are going for net zero. If you're just starting, fine, it's great. You simply just measure and improve.

‍

Tips to improve the metric: 

• Making your fleet use less fuel is the quickest way to reduce emissions. 
• Going EV is the biggie, but cutting idle time and using intelligent routing software will also help. 

‍

2. Vehicle maintenance & health metrics 

Maintenance metrics help you spot trouble before it sidelines your vehicles. When one vehicle strikes, it can upset an entire route, give late deliveries, and cut into margins. Fleets that track these numbers avoid unexpected breakdowns, costly repairs, and delayed deliveries. The more capable you become at this, the more reliable and profitable your fleet becomes.

‍

A. Preventive maintenance compliance

What it is: 

Scheduled maintenance of your vehicle is mandatory and with this metric, you can actually check things like brake checks, oil changes, tire rotations, and filter replacements. This metric tells how well you are doing the basic things to keep your vehicle in good shape. 

‍

Why it matters: 

Neglecting preventive maintenance is one of the fastest ways to kill a fleet’s uptime. Various studies indicate that improper maintenance contributes to roughly 12% of vehicle breakdowns, especially in commercial fleets. Moreover, unmaintained vehicles tend to break down at very bad times, either on delivery runs, during peak season, when a driver has just left the yard, etc. 

‍

Recently, I had a word with an operator who had a 72% compliance rate. However, most of his newly serviced vehicles often returned with recurring brake and engine problems. It was only after he implemented a maintenance tracking system that he was able to achieve the 90% compliance mark. Even,  he had a 30% decrease in unplanned repairs too within six months.

‍

How to calculate it:
Take the number of scheduled maintenance tasks you actually completed, divide it by the total number scheduled in a given period, then multiply by 100. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
The top-performing fleets usually try to keep it above 95 %. At least aim for 90%.  But make sure it doesn’t go below 80% and it will cost you more in reactive repairs.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• PM compliance has to be a shared priority between fleet managers, drivers, and service providers. 

• Use digital logs or automated reminders to avoid letting tasks fall through the cracks.

‍

B. Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF)

What it is:

MTBF is one of the most ignored fleet management metrics. This metric tells you how long your vehicles run between unexpected mechanical failures. Basically, you get an idea of how well you’re maintaining your vehicle, as it speaks volumes about the fleet’s overall reliability.

‍

Why it matters:
With a higher MTBF, your vehicles can stay in service longer, and you dont have to worry about those surprise repairs. It’s a good thing for delivery timelines, operating costs, and driver morale. 

‍

How to calculate it:
It’s pretty easy. Divide the total miles or hours operated by the number of failures during that period. Let’s say your fleet drove around 2,80,000 miles and had 20 breakdowns. Then the MFTB will be 2,80,000/20, which is equal to 14,000 miles.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
The acceptable range for light to medium duty fleets is within 12,000 and 15,000 miles between failures. However, also note that for class 8 trucks, MTBF can be 20,000+, depending on maintenance.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

Keep detailed repair logs. If the same part keeps failing across multiple vehicles, that’s your signal. With the right tool, you can easily identify the failure causes and pull patterns across your fleet so you can avoid repeat issues.

‍

C. Vehicle Downtime %

What it is:

This metric shows the percentage of time your vehicle was unavailable for deliveries. These could be due to reasons like repairs or maintenance. This also includes the time spent waiting for parts or being tied up in service queues. 

‍

Why it matters:
You are losing revenue daily when a vehicle is down. But let me tell you, it’s not always about the money. It’s also about the driver's frustration, delivery delays, and in some cases, penalty fees from clients. Make sure you consider vehicle downtime % as one of the important fleet management metrics.

‍

How to calculate it:
Take the total hours a vehicle was out of service during a time period and divide it by the total available hours. Multiply by 100 to get the percentage. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
The gold standard is under 5% (preferably for light-duty vehicles). But if it consistently shows above 10%, you need to rethink, as you’re likely losing contracts because of it.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Create maintenance schedules to keep backlogs at bay. 

• For those that depend on external garages, set SLAs to lock in repair windows or response times. 

• Build some slack in your plans (This is the most underrated one). One or two emergency vehicles can bear such shocks so your schedule does not get thrown into rather unnecessary chaos.

Also, don’t forget to analyze downtime causes. (Do this quarterly). Is it aging vehicles? Vendor delays? Maintenance bottlenecks? Different solutions are needed for each type of delay, so with this metric, you can find the root cause and fix it.

‍

3. Utilization & operational efficiency metrics

You can learn about routes and trip schedules from these metrics. For fleet operators, logistics managers, and even CFOs who wish to link operational output with cost effectiveness, these KPIs are essential.

‍

A. Vehicle utilization rate

What it is:
This indicator shows how your fleet is used to its overall availability. You get an idea whether your fleet is the right size or if you’re over- or under-invested in assets.

‍

Why it matters:
People often think “more vehicles = more capacity”! This is wrong. When your vehicle is underutilized, it can drain your finances. Therefore, there should always be a balance to optimize your asset ROI and minimize unnecessary capital expenses.

‍

How to calculate it:
Consider the total time the vehicle is in service and then divide it by the available time. Multiply the quotient by 100.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
Based on the industry and fleet size, the ideal target should be 70 to 85%. Never allow the figure to fall below 50 percent, as the inefficiency levels indicate excess capacity.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Reassign low-use vehicles to busy routes or you can simply give them to drivers with a packed schedule.

• Go for task rotation across your fleet and avoid any kind of overloading. 

• Sharing assets across departments (if you run a mixed-use fleet) helps too.

‍

B. Capacity utilization

This metric shows how much load capacity is used in each trip. In logistics, the standard units are in cubic feet/meters (for volume), and kilograms/tons (for weight). 

‍

Why it matters:

Half-empty trucks are like an airplane carrying 30 passengers in a 100-seat airplane. Maybe it gets the job done, but definitely nowhere near an option for cost efficiency. With time, that would mean higher cost per delivery and fuel wastage. The same goes for your fleets as well. 

‍

How to calculate it:

Divide the actual load carried by the maximum vehicle capacity and multiply by 100. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

Fleets with heavy logistics, a target of 80% is common. Anything lower, especially below 60%, casts doubt on how you plan your routes or deliveries.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Consider dynamic routing tools to group deliveries by distance and load compatibility.

• Better scheduling might also work, like consolidating orders going to the same area, which can boost fill rates faster. 

• Try rearranging loading patterns can free up space without opting for a larger truck.

‍

C. Average trip time 

As the name suggests, this metric tells you the average duration each trip takes. This includes the time from departure to return. It also considers factors like driving, stops, and loading/unloading time. 

‍

Why it matters:

If some routes take half an hour and others two hours without an actual reason behind them, your inefficiency stays hidden in everyday operations. Multiply that over hundreds of trips, and you get missed deliveries and tired-out drivers. 

‍

How to calculate it:

Record the total trip times for a period and divide by the number of trips that occurred.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

There exists no such thing as a standard, as it depends on your fleet size, geographic location, and industry. That said, if your average trip time goes up month after month with no added value (for instance, more deliveries per stop), then it’s a red flag! 

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Regularly audit your routes. Departing just 15 minutes later or earlier to avoid peak traffic can trim trip durations by 15-20 percent. 

• Give drivers real-time traffic information and let them choose their routing paths accordingly. 

• Ensure delivery addresses are accurate because incorrect GPS pins and locations are difficult to reach. This would mean wasting hours every single week.

‍

4. Safety & regulatory metrics

These are one of the fleet management metrics you don't really appreciate until something goes wrong. They don’t appear in revenue charts, but they hit hard when ignored. Be it a compliance violation, accident, or a driver walking away from the job, all these numbers speak volumes about the reliability and sustainability of your fleet. Regulators, insurers, and your customers are all paying attention. You should, too.

‍

A. Driver safety score

What is it:

The driver safety score is like a report card in which you track how your drivers are performing. This report usually comes with a lot of important data, like speeding, hard braking, sharp turns, distracted driving, and even seatbelt use. 

‍

Why it matters:

Around 168k trucks meet with accidents every year, of which 3% results in fatality and 32% involves injury. That means a loss to your people and your business reputation. These crashes can easily be prevented through proper training. Safe drivers protect your people, your vehicle, and your reputation. A good safety score helps you spot risk early, offer coaching before there’s an incident, and even negotiate better insurance premiums.

‍

How to calculate it:
If you are using a fleet telematics system, then it will get the job done by logging driving behaviors and assigning weighted values. In case you are doing it manually, you will need to track individual infractions and normalize them over distance or time.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
As for benchmarks, 85 and above is a good score. But if this rate goes below 70, it’s essential to review the driver’s habits and also provide coaching if needed.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Share scores whenever possible. The feedback must be constructive, and you should share it in a supportive way, not as punishment. 

• Set improvement goals. Try to gamify it a little by recognizing the safest drivers each quarter. 

• Offer safety orientation to your new drivers. 

‍

B. Driver turnover rate

What is it? 

This one’s pretty simple. It’s the number of drivers leaving within a stipulated time, usually within a year. The rate is essential as it shows how good you are at retaining talent. 

‍

Why it matters:
Driver turnovers are not a logistical problem but a financial constraint.  You need to invest in onboarding and training your new drivers when your old driver leaves. Also, a churn rate affects your delivery schedule, and it’s a matter of business reputation.

‍

How to calculate it:
Take the number of drivers who left during a given period, divide it by your average number of drivers for that same period. Multiply the quotient by 100.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:
Keep it under 30%. If you're crossing 60% regularly, it's time to dig into what's pushing drivers away.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Listen to your drivers. Conduct a thorough exit interview and then take action based on the information shared. 

• Provide better schedules, newer vehicles, and more local runs. 

• Recognize them for their hard work and efforts, as this can make them think twice before leaving. 

‍

C. Incident rate per 100K miles

What is it?

It measures the frequency with which accidents, wrecks, or safety-related events happen in your fleet within 100,000 miles of driving. It serves to standardize incident counting across all types of fleet sizes and volumes of miles.

‍

Why it matters:

Each incident hits you with repair costs, insurance premiums, and ruins the credibility of your brand. A slight increase in an incident rate might be sufficient to knock you out of the race for big contracts in logistics or construction. Some clients could even ask you to show your safety metrics before they think of closing a deal.

‍

How to calculate it:

Consider the number of total safety incidents within a stipulated timeframe, divide that by total miles driven, and multiply by 1,00,000. 

‍

Benchmarks or target:

For commercial fleets, try to keep it below the range from 0.05 to 0.07 incidents per 100K miles. Above 1.0 is when you really start questioning your safety procedures, from driver training up through vehicle conditions.

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Identify the root cause. Are certain drivers presenting a higher number of incidents? Are routes or vehicle types more prone? Fling some data at them. 

• Use dashcam footage to understand an event. Then start acting on prevention: regular safety refreshers for your drivers, rotating long-haul drivers to avoid fatigue, and real-time communication between dispatch and road teams. 

‍

D. CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) Score

What it is:

The CSA score is a safety rating system established by the FMCSA (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration). They look at your fleet's crash history, roadside inspections, violations, and various other safety-related information. Consider it a report card for safety and compliance in the operation of your fleet.

‍

Why it matters:

A bad score will invite audit after audit, costly insurance premiums, and have your vehicles tagged for more roadside inspections. With a consistently poor CSA, you can even lose potential business deals. 

‍

How do you calculate it:

The FMCSA takes care of the calculation rather than you trying your hand at it. They go through data in seven BASICs (Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories) concerning unsafe driving, hours-of-service compliance, and vehicle maintenance. The percentile ranks go from 0 to 100 in each category, with lower being good. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

While there isn't an order of importance, the typical rule is to keep the score below 50. That’s a safe zone. Once a score hits 65 for any category, it’s not a good sign. If your fleet is carrying any kind of hazardous material, then the threshold is stricter.  

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Check your CSA profile as often as possible. Sometimes, violations may have been recorded inaccurately, and you can challenge them.

• Train your drivers on essential compliance topics like proper logging and load securement. 

• Make sure your maintenance team isn’t skipping pre-trip inspections. Even small improvements can show up in your CSA score. 

‍

5. Financial metrics

Financial metrics allow you to see where your money flows: into fuel, maintenance, depreciation, and so on. These figures help you cut costs and assist you in budgeting, pricing your service adequately, and in decision-making, such as when to replace a vehicle or switch leasing options.

‍

A. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

What it is:

TCO attempts to capture the entire life cycle cost of a vehicle and not just its sticker price . This includes the price acquisition cost, fuel, maintenance, insurance, depreciation, and aids in the resale value.

‍

Why it matters:

Suppose you are thinking whether you want to keep an old truck or buy a new one, TCO can give you clarity that will help you decide. Sometimes a truck looks cheaper upfront, but in the long run, it costs more due to downtime and repairs.

‍

How to calculate it:

TCO = Purchase Price + Operating Costs (fuel, maintenance, insurance) – Residual Value (what you sell it for later). You can compute this either on a per-vehicle or fleet-wide basis, on an annual basis, or on a life cycle basis (usually 5–7 years).

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

Try to keep the TCO under $0.60–$0.70 per mile. This range is ideal for light-duty vehicles but not heavy trucks. In the case of electric fleets, TCO may trend lower over time due to reduced fuel and maintenance. 

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Invest in preventative maintenance and timely retirement of those vehicles that incur high maintenance costs. 

• Monitor your TCO continuously and do not allow surprises at year-end.

‍

B. Cost per mile/kilometer

What it is:

Cost per Mile/Kilometer is the total expense required to operate a vehicle for every mile or kilometer of the distance traveled. It includes fixed and variable costs- fuel, maintenance, insurance, depreciation, tires, and wage payments to the driver.

‍

Why it matters:

Arguably, one of the most important fleet management metrics, it shows the real operational cost of any delivery, trip, or haul. Whether it is for pricing contracts, budgeting for fuel, or comparing vehicle types, all these activities could use this one figure to quantify what every movement costs the business. A small increase in cost per mile across an entire fleet can eat deeply into margins.

‍

How to calculate it:

Consider all operating expenses for a vehicle/fleet during a given time period and divide by the distance covered in that same period.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

They differ extremely across types of fleets and regions. As per the ATRI report of 2023, the average cost per mile for trucking U.S. fleets amounted to $2.27, including driver wages, fuel, maintenance, and so on. For smaller fleets or light-duty vehicle fleets, costs could be anywhere between $0.50 and $1.00 per mile, depending on the type of asset and how it is used. 

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Track idle time, enforce speed control policy, and fuel cards with reporting.

• Schedule maintenance based on predictive technologies and avoid fix-reactive patches.

• Use the best route optimization tool like Fynd TMS.

• Watch out for bad driving behavior. The cost per mile ups significantly with hard braking, rapid acceleration, and speeding.

• Do not waste heavy-duty vehicles on tasks that lighter, more economical vehicles can do.

A quick tip for you: Integrate telematics with a cost analytics platform. Get real-time visibility into per-mile cost breakdowns. 

‍

C. Maintenance cost per vehicle

What is it:

Maintenance cost per vehicle is the expenditure you make on a single vehicle to maintain its efficiency within a time frame. The costs are often associated with filter replacements, oil changes, and corrective repairs.

‍

Why it matters:

You get to know the cost efficiency of your assets over time with this metric. Higher costs mean your vehicle is getting old or you are not maintaining it properly.

‍

How to calculate it:

Sum up all maintenance costs for your fleet over a time period, then divide by the number of vehicles.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

Benchmarks vary depending on the vehicle class and industry. However, updated benchmarks from Utilimarc or ATRI have set a standard that you can follow as well. Here it is:

• Light-duty vehicles (cars, vans, pickups): Avg cost is $0.064 and $0.096 per mile ($1,600–$2,400/yr)

• Medium-duty trucks: Current cost sits closer to $0.16 to $0.214 per mile which is $4,000–$5,350/yr

• Heavy-duty trucks (Class 8): Presently it's $0.216 per mile, which is $21,600/yr (fuel/parts excluded)

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Develop a schedule for preventive maintenance and follow OEM recommendations.

• Install telematics and diagnostic tools to identify faults early and avoid big fixes.

• Track costs by vehicle age and type to maintain older assets.

• Offer regular training to your drivers.

• Ensure labor hours are logged accurately to avoid over-servicing.

‍

6. Delivery & customer experience metrics

This set of metrics tracks the ability of your fleet operations to satisfy customer expectations. It is beyond mere moving of goods from point A to point B: it's about ensuring that they are delivered on time. These KPIs are important for fleet managers to assert operational efficiencies with customer-centric service. 

‍

A. On-time delivery rate

What it is:

This metric shows how many shipments your fleet has delivered on time. It shows if your fleet is reliable in reaching customers on time, which greatly supports your reputation with customers.

‍

Why it matters:

Not receiving deliveries on schedule may hurt customer satisfaction, lead to fewer renewals, and result in penalties that are part of SLAs. If products are not delivered at the right time in B2B or the last-mile sector, it can damage everyone’s reputation and cut into company profits.

‍

How to calculate it:

This is figured out by dividing deliveries that were on time by total deliveries for the same time period, then multiplying by 100.

‍

Benchmarks or targets:

• B2B logistics and freight: 95–98%

• E-commerce/last-mile: 90–95%

• The top performers in operations aim for more than 98%

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• GPS routing, real-time traffic alerts, and on-the-fly route re-optimization

• Allow buffer times while scheduling for high-risk delivery windows

• Monitor driver performance and delay patterns with telematics

• Measure reasons for delay (warehouse-related, weather, traffic) and fix them

‍

CASE STUDY: Domino’s 30-Minute Delivery Guarantee — A Timeless Warning

Old is gold, especially when a past lesson still holds wise advice. The Domino’s 30-minute delivery guarantee case illustrates well how strong pressure from within a company can make people make incorrect strategic choices.

‍

The 1980s saw Domino’s grow rapidly through a strong pledge: Delivery will arrive in 30 minutes or less. If not, then it’s free. It got off to a good start, with rapid expansion, more loyal customers, and a 15% share of the national pizza market. Still, the cost of it was extremely high behind the scenes. Drivers tried to beat their time. Accidents mounted.

‍

‍By 1988, there were at least 20 deaths reported because of delivery mishaps. Many lawsuits were then filed, totaling more than 200 cases, and one of them resulted in a $78 million judgment. Around 1993, the company ended its guarantee. Public pressure, the risk of lawsuits, and the responsibility to do the right thing were the main reasons for the decision.

‍

I still refer to this case now, even though it came about many decades ago. Because the same question arises for all logistics firms, gig delivery platforms, and e-commerce fleets: How do you promise speed without burning out your people or risking lives? As customer expectations go higher and delivery tracking happens instantly, the pressure is now on apps and algorithms, not people.

‍

As a result, it is necessary to track figures like On-Time Delivery Rate with strategy, not with emotions. Fynd TMS makes dispatching easy, adjusts to current delays, and optimizes routes, all without going beyond safety limits.

‍

B. Delivery accuracy

What is it:

If you want to know how accurately your fleet has delivered to the correct location, including the correct shipments, this is the metric you need to track. This metric combines multiple factors, such as routing, timing, and order integrity, into a single powerful performance indicator.

‍

Why it matters:

Accuracy is sometimes deemed more important than speed. I was recently reviewing a study that found that 48% of customers report stopping their purchases from a retailer after two or more late or incorrect deliveries. 

‍

A fast-but-wrong delivery may lead to costly issues such as returns, redeliveries, complaints, and lost business. For industries such as e-commerce, food, pharma, and B2B distributions, wrong or missed deliveries can jeopardize long-term customer relationships.

‍

How to calculate it:

Delivery Accuracy = Number of error-free deliveries divided by the total deliveries*100 to get the percentage. But there is a hitch: the idea of "accurate" itself must be an explicit term. Usually, it means every company will deliver to the correct address, within a specified window of time; the right orders (complete), so they don't come back as complaints, damage claims, or requests for redelivery. 

‍

Benchmarks or targets: 

What is considered "good" in terms of delivery accuracy depends on the specific industry. Retail or e-commerce fleet accuracy is ideally around 95-98%. If your fleets are into same-day deliveries, the % should be between 90 and 92. But in cases where temperature-sensitive shipments are involved could have real-world consequences for any kind of mistakes, so expectations are very high, almost 100%. 

‍

Tips to improve the metric:

• Use Route optimization software to make sure that drivers follow the most efficient routes.

• Digitalize proof-of-delivery (POD) to increase traceability.

• Audit failed shipments. Try to find out the reasons behind the failure. 

• Invest in driver education. If you have a clear SOP and a very good onboarding process, the chances of mistakes decrease.

• Synchronize your inventory and order management to keep order accuracy intact.

So, that’s all about the different fleet management metrics you should be tracking in 2025. But the real question is: are you tracking all of them? Or, you’re just about to discover what critical insight you've been missing all along? 

How to monitor, analyze & act on metrics

Now comes the bigger question: What do you actually do with all this information? It has been easy enough to collect the data. But the process of using that data to craft better decisions, faster fleets, and fewer headaches is where the challenge really lies. 

‍

Here's how I have learned to cut through the noise and make metrics matter.

‍

1. Choose the right tools 

If you are tracking things manually, you are already behind. GPS sensors, fuel meters, and diagnostic devices are your eyes and ears on the road. But if there isn't a system just for bringing it all together, you will drown in spreadsheets. 

‍

Fynd TMS has honestly made a difference in my own workflows. Tracking vehicles, managing drivers, route optimization, live order tracking, etc., are all integrated within one clean dashboard, so no switching back and forth between tabs.

‍

2. Create dashboards & reports that actually get used

Using complex dashboards defeats the whole purpose. Your data should work for you, not intimidate your team. The trick is to send out weekly digests. Give department analytics at a glance. Make it easy for anyone from dispatchers to CEOs to get what they need to know. 

‍

3. Involve drivers & frontline teams in performance improvement

This is a pretty big one. You can't improve fleet metrics from an armchair. Include drivers, warehouse managers, and loaders. Show them the data, talk through the goals, and ask them for input on what they think might be achievable.

‍

4. Set your goals, alerts, and review intervals 

Set monthly goals for key indicators: fuel efficiency, reduction in downtime, and so on. Set up an alert that emails you whenever the performance is below a set threshold. Plan regular review sessions not only for catching problems but also for applauding wins!

‍

You'll be surprised how motivating it will be to hear, "Hey, we shaved 8% off of our idle time this month." That momentum grooms the culture of lots of results in no time. Metrics matter only when they get you into action. Weigh in with the right systems, and from tracking, you will end up at optimization in no time.